Sanibel Beaches (Lighthouse, Bowman’s, West Gulf, Knapp’s Point)
Overview: The Gulf beaches of Sanibel Island offer surfcasting opportunities for a wide range of species. Fishing is influenced by tides, bait schools, and seasonal
Since 1971, The Historic Bait Box has been the go-to spot for fishermen and island adventurers on Sanibel and Captiva. Whether you’re planning to reel in a trophy catch or help your kids cast their first line, we’re your one-stop shop for beach days and boating adventures. We carry beach gear, coolers, tackle, live bait, frozen local bait, and shelling equipment. We are world-famous for our cast nets. You’ll also find branded Sanibel and Captiva Island apparel, tide charts, fishing tips, local tourist info, and charters to help you make the most of your time on the water.
Our bait is caught fresh nightly to ensure top quality. Stop in, or give us a call at (239) 472-1618—we’re always happy to talk shop and help you plan your next island adventure!
Since opening its doors in 1971, The Historic Bait Box has earned its reputation as Sanibel’s premier fishing supply shop. Now under the ownership of Matt Joyce, we proudly continue a 50-year tradition of serving both locals and visitors. Our friendly, knowledgeable staff is always on hand to ensure you have an unforgettable fishing experience every time you stop by.
Experience the best of Sanibel and Captiva Islands aboard one of our charter services. Let a knowledgeable local captain guide you on a day of exceptional fishing or scenic exploration. With half-day and full-day trips available for the whole family, we’re here to help you create unforgettable memories.
From rods, reels, and tackle to shell scoops, spikes, and our world-famous cast nets, The Historic Bait Box has everything to help you reel in a big catch or uncover that perfect shell. Swing by to gear up, grab a tide chart, get expert fishing tips, or book the charter of a lifetime!
At The Historic Bait Box, we proudly stock top-brand fishing supplies and apparel designed for both fun and safety. Our freshly caught live and frozen bait comes straight from local waters. We also offer rental and repair services for rods, reels, and other tackle—so even if the one that got away takes your line, you’ll be back on the water in no time! Our range of UV-protective fishing and boating wear, along with high-quality sunscreens and lotions, ensures you’re comfortable and safe wherever your journey takes you.
Our photo gallery showcases impressive catches from our amazing community of anglers—both ours and yours! Share your proudest moments by submitting your photos to our Facebook page or use our online form to upload directly. Join the conversation and you might see your catch featured next!
Catch the latest updates on Sanibel’s best fishing spots, bait tips, and seasonal trends.
Overview: The Gulf beaches of Sanibel Island offer surfcasting opportunities for a wide range of species. Fishing is influenced by tides, bait schools, and seasonal
Overview: This expansive estuarine complex features mangrove islands, oyster bars, and deepwater channels. It is a premier area for inshore species and also supports seasonal
Overview: Sanibel Pier offers excellent access to Gulf waters, with structure and current flow that attract a wide variety of species. This site is ideal
Overview: This protected estuarine system offers miles of mangrove-lined creeks, culverts, and flats ideal for shallow-water anglers. Limited boat access helps preserve consistent fish populations,
Overview: Blind Pass, the narrow waterway separating Sanibel and Captiva Islands, is one of the most dynamic and productive fishing locations in the region. Strong
Overview: The Causeway Islands provide easily accessible fishing from shore, bridges, or boat. Anglers can target species in both shallow grass flats and deeper channels